The Painted Pony Restaurant - Bethlehem, CTThe Painted Pony Restaurant

Print Menu

menu: Primary


breaded mozzarella 

hand cut & fried wedges, house marinara, crispy parsley

cheese curds poutine 

breaded wisconsin curds, demi-glace, shredded short ribs, beer cheese drizzle

classic shrimp cocktail 

poached white shrimp, classic cocktail sauce or coconut curry dipping sauce

fried calamari & olives 

lightly fried, crispy capers, house cured olives, lemon

hummus & warm pita 

roasted pepita seed, tahini, harvest vegetables

jalapeƱo popper dip 

cream cheese, cheddar & mozzarella, roasted hot peppers, bacon, green onion, warm bavarian pretzels

pork belly & pickles board 

sweet & spicy chili glazed pork belly slabs, house made pickled onions & cucumbers, cinnamon chipotle chips


always at the pony... bone-in or tenders choose: classic buffalo, hot honey, bbq or jala-mango served with bleu cheese, ranch or honey mustard



avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese, pork belly lardons, tomatoes, chopped greens


cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, olives, peppers, shredded carrots, field greens, house croutons


local feta, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, chopped romaine


sweetened cranberries, glazed pecans, bosc pears, gorgonzola cheese, harvest greens


carrots & cauliflower 

roasted carrots, charred onion, riced cauliflower risotto, romesco

eggplant napoleon 

breaded eggplant, roasted peppers, zucchini, mozzarella, capellini, tomato sauce

faroe island salmon 

orange honey, dukkha seasoned, cauliflower risotto, burnt pine

fish & chips 

golden ale battered haddock, potatoes, tarter sauce, house slaw

gnocchi & short ribs 

veal demi-glace, cream, shredded short ribs, carrots, onions, herbs

mac & cheese 

cheddar gouda blend, shell pasta add short ribs 8, add pork belly 6

pan seared scallops 

white wine, butter, lemon, capellini, crispy capers

pappardelle alfredo 

ribbon pasta, creamy pesto, roasted tomato add shrimp 6


avocado toast 

whole grain bread, tomatoes, pickled red onions add bacon 2


8oz house choice blend, pickled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, brioche bun bacon, caramelized onions, avocado


marinated & grilled breast, jalapeno & bacon cheese, fire roasted peppers, avocado, schiacciata bread

chicken & waffles 

buttermilk fried chicken breast, roasted jalapeno jam, heirloom tomato salata, cheddar cheese & green onion Belgian waffle, smoked chili aioli

chicken parm 

hand breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan roll

eggplant parm 

hand breaded eggplant, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan roll

pork belly 

hot honey, pickles, house slaw, smashed curds, cajun crema, brioche bun

steak & cheese 

cheddar, caramelized onions, shaven prime rib, bourbon demi-glace for dipping

Steaks & Chop

braised short ribs 

10oz, bourbon pan gravy

Kansas city strip 

14oz bone-in striploin

pork rib chop 

duroc pork, brown sugar & sea salt, poached pear chutney, tuscan potatoes

prime rib ...always at the pony 

10oz | 16oz | 22oz au jus, horseradish cream

ribeye filet 

12oz ribeye roll

tenderloin medallions 

wild mushrooms, whiskey demi-glace, mashed potatoes, roasted heirloom carrots

Bar Snacks

house chips 

cinnamon chipotle seasoning, cajun sour cream dip

house cured olives 

calabrian chili, toasted rosemary, garlic

toasted nuts 

pecans, almonds, walnuts, brown sugar, chili pepper glaze

Pony Classics

chicken alexander 

breaded chicken breast, white Wine, mushrooms, mozzarella

chicken caruso 

breaded chicken breast, shrimp, broccoli, Newburgh sauce

chicken parmigiana 

breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, capellini

new england baked cod 

cracker crumbs, white wine & butter roasted cod, choose two sides

Flat Breads

Build your own 

red sauce or fig jam, mozzarella or cheddar 9 | add chicken 2, short ribs 3, pork belly 3, feta 2, gorgonzola 2, fresh mozzarella 2, spinach 1, peppers 1, onions 1, tomatoes 1, mushrooms 1, olives 1

fig, onions, pork belly & gorgonzola 

mission fig jam, caramelized onions, pork belly lardons

kalamata, feta & spinach 

alfredo, tomato, lemon peel, red onion

roasted tomato & artichoke 

garlic oil, mozzarella blend, basil pesto

Short ribs, green onions & asiago 

braised & shredded short ribs, tomato, beer cheese drizzle


ancient grains 


avgolemeno soup 


house fries 


house slaw 


mashed pots 


onion rings 


riced cauliflower 


roasted carrots 


roasted potatoes 


soup otd 




sweet tots 


tossed salad