The Painted Pony Restaurant - Bethlehem, CTThe Painted Pony Restaurant
203-266-5771


Print Menu

menu: Primary


Beginnings

breaded mozzarella 

$9.00
hand cut & fried wedges, house marinara, crispy parsley

cheese curds poutine 

$10.00
breaded wisconsin curds, demi-glace, shredded short ribs, beer cheese drizzle

classic shrimp cocktail 

$13.00
poached white shrimp, classic cocktail sauce or coconut curry dipping sauce

fried calamari & olives 

$12.00
lightly fried, crispy capers, house cured olives, lemon

hummus & warm pita 

$10.00
roasted pepita seed, tahini, harvest vegetables

jalapeƱo popper dip 

$8.00
cream cheese, cheddar & mozzarella, roasted hot peppers, bacon, green onion, warm bavarian pretzels

pork belly & pickles board 

$11.00
sweet & spicy chili glazed pork belly slabs, house made pickled onions & cucumbers, cinnamon chipotle chips

wings 

$9.00
always at the pony... bone-in or tenders choose: classic buffalo, hot honey, bbq or jala-mango served with bleu cheese, ranch or honey mustard

Salads

cobb 

$11.00
avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese, pork belly lardons, tomatoes, chopped greens

garden 

$8.00
cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, olives, peppers, shredded carrots, field greens, house croutons

Greek 

$9.00
local feta, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, chopped romaine

harvest 

$9.00
sweetened cranberries, glazed pecans, bosc pears, gorgonzola cheese, harvest greens

Mains

carrots & cauliflower 

$15.00
roasted carrots, charred onion, riced cauliflower risotto, romesco

eggplant napoleon 

$16.00
breaded eggplant, roasted peppers, zucchini, mozzarella, capellini, tomato sauce

faroe island salmon 

$24.00
orange honey, dukkha seasoned, cauliflower risotto, burnt pine

fish & chips 

$17.00
golden ale battered haddock, potatoes, tarter sauce, house slaw

gnocchi & short ribs 

$23.00
veal demi-glace, cream, shredded short ribs, carrots, onions, herbs

mac & cheese 

$12.00
cheddar gouda blend, shell pasta add short ribs 8, add pork belly 6

pan seared scallops 

$24.00
white wine, butter, lemon, capellini, crispy capers

pappardelle alfredo 

$14.00
ribbon pasta, creamy pesto, roasted tomato add shrimp 6

Hands

avocado toast 

$10.00
whole grain bread, tomatoes, pickled red onions add bacon 2

burger 

$12.00
8oz house choice blend, pickled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, brioche bun bacon, caramelized onions, avocado

chicken 

$11.00
marinated & grilled breast, jalapeno & bacon cheese, fire roasted peppers, avocado, schiacciata bread

chicken & waffles 

$13.00
buttermilk fried chicken breast, roasted jalapeno jam, heirloom tomato salata, cheddar cheese & green onion Belgian waffle, smoked chili aioli

chicken parm 

$10.00
hand breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan roll

eggplant parm 

$9.00
hand breaded eggplant, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan roll

pork belly 

$13.00
hot honey, pickles, house slaw, smashed curds, cajun crema, brioche bun

steak & cheese 

$13.00
cheddar, caramelized onions, shaven prime rib, bourbon demi-glace for dipping

Steaks & Chop

braised short ribs 

$24.00
10oz, bourbon pan gravy

Kansas city strip 

$32.00
14oz bone-in striploin

pork rib chop 

$23.00
duroc pork, brown sugar & sea salt, poached pear chutney, tuscan potatoes

prime rib ...always at the pony 

$18.00
10oz | 16oz | 22oz au jus, horseradish cream

ribeye filet 

$29.00
12oz ribeye roll

tenderloin medallions 

$28.00
wild mushrooms, whiskey demi-glace, mashed potatoes, roasted heirloom carrots

Bar Snacks

house chips 

$5.00
cinnamon chipotle seasoning, cajun sour cream dip

house cured olives 

$5.00
calabrian chili, toasted rosemary, garlic

toasted nuts 

$5.00
pecans, almonds, walnuts, brown sugar, chili pepper glaze

Pony Classics

chicken alexander 

$19.00
breaded chicken breast, white Wine, mushrooms, mozzarella

chicken caruso 

$22.00
breaded chicken breast, shrimp, broccoli, Newburgh sauce

chicken parmigiana 

$18.00
breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, capellini

new england baked cod 

$18.00
cracker crumbs, white wine & butter roasted cod, choose two sides

Flat Breads

Build your own 

$9.00
red sauce or fig jam, mozzarella or cheddar 9 | add chicken 2, short ribs 3, pork belly 3, feta 2, gorgonzola 2, fresh mozzarella 2, spinach 1, peppers 1, onions 1, tomatoes 1, mushrooms 1, olives 1

fig, onions, pork belly & gorgonzola 

$14.00
mission fig jam, caramelized onions, pork belly lardons

kalamata, feta & spinach 

$13.00
alfredo, tomato, lemon peel, red onion

roasted tomato & artichoke 

$14.00
garlic oil, mozzarella blend, basil pesto

Short ribs, green onions & asiago 

$14.00
braised & shredded short ribs, tomato, beer cheese drizzle

Sides

ancient grains 

$5.00

avgolemeno soup 

$5.00

house fries 

$4.00

house slaw 

$5.00

mashed pots 

$5.00

onion rings 

$6.00

riced cauliflower 

$5.00

roasted carrots 

$5.00

roasted potatoes 

$5.00

soup otd 

$5.00

spinach 

$5.00

sweet tots 

$5.00

tossed salad 

$5.00