74 Main St South, Bethlehem, CT 06751 (opens in a new tab) (203) 266-5771
Order Online (opens in a new tab)
powered by BentoBox (opens in a new tab)
74 Main St South, Bethlehem, CT 06751 (opens in a new tab) (203) 266-5771
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

Chef's Cut

Choose two sides

  • Braised Short Ribs

    $36

    10oz, house braised veal demi-glace

  • Delmonico

    Market Price

    14oz off-the-bone ribeye, garlic butter

  • New York Trip

    Market Price

    12oz boneless striploin gorgonzola butter

  • Pork Spareribs

    House bourbon caramel BBQ sauce

    ½ Rack $20

    Full Rack $38

  • Prime Rib

    Au jus, horseradish cream

    10az per Market Price

    16oz per Market Price

    22oz per Market Price

  • Steak Tips

    $34

    Pan seared, caramelized onions, mushrooms & peppers

Kids Menu

  • Mac N Cheese

    $9

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    $10

  • Chicken Tenders & Fries

    $9

  • Pasta & Sauce

    $8

  • Cheese Pizza

    $9

  • Grilled Chicken & Veggies

    $10

Sides

  • Baked Potato

    $6

  • Roasted Potatoes

    $6

  • Mashed potatoes

    $6

  • Sweet Mashed Puree

    $6

  • Chef's Daily Veg

    $6

    Seasonal

  • Broccoli

    $6

  • Brussels

    $6

  • Spinach

    $6

  • Hand Cut Fries

    $6

  • Sweet Potato Fries

    $6

  • Onion Rings

    $6

  • Garden Salad

    $6

  • Caesar Salad

    $6

Mains

Served with a choice of soup or salad

  • Fish & Chips

    $22

    Golden ale battered haddock, house cut fries, tartar sauce

  • Baked Stuffed Scallops

    $27

    Sea scallops, crab & shrimp stuffing, brown butter, fresh herbs, lemon, sweet mashed, brussels sprouts

  • Rosemary Chicken

    $22

    Parmesan crusted chicken breast, herbed compound butter, shaved brussels, rosemary roasted potatoes

  • Pecan Crusted Norwegian Salmon

    $28

    Pecans, maple dijon glaze, flat leaf spinach, sweet potato puree

  • Baked Ravioli

    $25

    Four cheese blend, bolognese, mozzarella

  • Asiago Stuffed Gnocchi

    $26

    Brown butter, sage, shaved parm, arugula

Pony Classics

Served with a choice of soup or salad

  • Chicken Alexander

    $24

    Breaded chicken breast, white wine, mushrooms, mozzarella, angel hair pasta

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    $24

    Breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, angel hair pasta

  • Chicken Piccata

    $26

    Egg dipped chicken breast, butter wine sauce, capers, fresh lemon, angel hair pasta

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    $23

    Egg dipped filets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh herbs, angel hair pasta

  • New England Baked Cod

    $24

    Cracker crumbs, white wine & butter roasted cod, roasted potatoes, broccoli

  • Mac N Cheese

    $18

    Cast iron baked shell pasta, cheddar, mozzarella, gouda, cracker topping

    Add Short Rib $8

    Add Buffalo Chicken Tender $6

Starters & Shareables

  • Baked Feta

    $14

    Olive oil, paprika, fresh oregano, served with crostini

  • Whipped Ricotta

    $14

    Crushed pecan, fig jam, lemon zest, served with crostini

  • Jalapeno Popper Dip

    $16

    Cream cheese, cheddar, mozzarella, roasted hot peppers, bacon, green onion, warm Bavarian pretzels

  • Breaded Mozzarella

    $14

    Hand cut & fried wedges, house marinara, crispy parsley

  • Fried Calamari

    $14

    Lightly dusted and golden fried

  • Pony Style Calamari

    $18

    Gorgonzola, hot cherry peppers & balsamic glaze

  • Littleneck Clams

    $16

    Garlic butter, fresh herbs, crostini

  • Wings: Bone-In or Tenders

    Choose: classic buffalo, hot honey, BBQ or jala-mango served with bleu cheese, ranch or honey mustard

    Eight Piece $16

    Four Piece Boneless $14

Salads

  • Caesar

    $12

    Crisp romaine, house croutons, shredded parmesan, Caesar dressing

  • Cobb

    $15

    Avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese, crushed bacon, tomatoes, chopped greens

  • Garden

    $11

    Cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, olives, peppers, shredded carrots, field greens, house croutons

  • Greek

    $14

    Local feta, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, Kalamata olives, chopped romaine

  • Harvest

    $14

    Sweetened cranberries, glazed pecans, pears, Gorgonzola cheese, harvest greens

  • Fried Goat Cheese & Beet Salad

    $15

    Crisp romaine, red onion, citrus vinaigrette

Add Ons

Chicken $6, Steak $12, Salmon $10

Flatbread

  • Fig, Crispy Prosciutto & Blue Cheese

    $17

    Mission fig jam, sherry pickled onions, arugula, rosemary oil

  • Short Ribs, Green Onions & Asiago

    $17

    Braised & shredded short ribs, tomato, beer cheese drizzle

  • Pear, Brie & Chicken

    $17

    Sliced seasonal pears, grilled chicken, brie cheese arugula, caramelized onion

  • Spinach & Artichoke

    $16

    Sundried tomato, feta & mozzarella

  • Caprese

    $15

    Fresh tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze

  • Build Your Own

    $12

    Red sauce or Alfredo, mozzarella or cheddar

    Cauliflower Crust $3

    ADD

    Chicken $4

    Short Ribs $5

    Feta $3

    Gorgonzola $3

    Fresh Mozzarella $3

    Spinach $2

    Peppers $2

    Onions $2

    Tomatoes $2

    Mushrooms

    Olives $2

Add Ons

Chicken $6, Steak $12, Salmon $10

Fresh Pasta

Served with garden salad or soup. Add shrimp for $8. Choice of Tagliatelle or Bucatini, Sub gluten free pasta $3

  • Classic Pasta Dishes

    Choose pasta, choose sauce

    Marinara $14

    Alfredo or Pesto $16

    Ala Vodka $18

    Add Meatballs $6

    Add Chicken $6

    Add Salmon $10

  • Bolognese

    $21

    Traditional slow-cooked beef & tomatoes, parmesan cheese, fresh herbs

  • Seafood Arrabbiata

    $26

    Calamari, shrimp, scallops & clams, spicy garlic & tomato sauce, toasted fennel, parmesan cheese

  • Pasta E Carbonara

    $20

    Creamy Alfredo sauce with bacon, peas & parmesan

  • White Clam Sauce

    $24

    Fresh littleneck clams, garlic, white wine broth, virgin oil, parsley

  • Broccoli Rabe with Sausage or Chicken

    $22

    Garlic oil, shaved parmesan

  • One Pan Alfredo

    Tomato, artichoke, spinach, shaved parmesan

    Add Chicken $6

    Add Steak $12

    Salmon $10

Hands

Served with choice of hand cut fries, salad or slaw

  • Pony Burger

    $16

    Bacon, cheddar, BBQ, onion rings

  • Bistro Burger*

    $17

    8oz choice blend, caramelized onions, Gorgonzola cheese, fig jam, brioche

  • House Burger*

    $15

    8oz choice blend, house pickled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, brioche

    Add Bacon $2

    Add Cheese $1

    Add Avocado $3

  • Steak & Cheese Wrap

    $17

    Cheddar, caramelized onions, shaved prime rib, bourbon demi-glace for dipping

  • Short Rib Grilled Cheese

    $18

    Texas toast, hot honey BBQ, gouda & mozzarella

  • Southern Fried Crispy Chicken

    $17

    Fried chicken breast, hot honey, pickles, creamy 'chicken' sauce, pickles, house slaw

  • Chicken Avocado

    $16

    Marinated & grilled chicken breast, smoked bacon, tomatoes, ripe avocado, lemon aioli

    Add Cheese $1

  • Parms

    $16

    Fried chicken or eggplant, house marinara, melted mozzarella, tuscan roll

Before placing your order, please inform your server if anyone in your party has a food allergy. **Allergy alert: our pesto contains pine nuts**

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness